Independent panel identifies areas of learning and progress in police cases

An independent panel reviewing the use of police powers in Avon and Somerset has published its latest quarterly report, reviewing a number of cases and highlighting areas of learning.

The Independent Scrutiny of Police Powers Panel (ISoPPP) – made up of volunteers from the public – reviews police cases and scrutinises how the police have exercised their powers, to ensure they are being used appropriately and proportionately and to identify areas of learning.

Over the last quarter, the panel reviewed 15 randomly selected cases and two Special Review Cases (SRCs) chosen due to their public interest, complexity or learning value. While the panel praised individual officers for remaining calm and engaging respectfully in challenging circumstances, it found that there were missed opportunities for de-escalation and better communication.

Three of the 15 cases reviewed were referred for a structured feedback process involving nine officers, supporting more detailed reflection and professional development. In addition, seven Good Work letters were issued to officers in recognition of effective and proportionate policing.

Clare Moody, Police and Crime Commissioner, said: “The volunteers on ISoPPP work with exceptional dedication and expertise to support me in holding policing to account. Independent scrutiny like this is essential for strengthening transparency, accountability, and learning in policing. Crucially, it ensures that the voices and perspectives of our communities are heard and inform my role scrutinising the use of police powers.”

Desmond Brown MBE, Chair of the Independent Scrutiny of Police Powers Panel, said: “Together, these outcomes demonstrate the panel’s continued commitment not only to identifying areas for improvement, but also to recognising good practice and contributing to meaningful organisational learning. Our focus remains on ensuring that independent scrutiny provides clear, evidence-based feedback that supports accountability, transparency, and positive change in the use of police powers across Avon and Somerset.”

You can read the latest quarterly report here.