Community-led oversight strengthens police accountability in 2025

The Independent Scrutiny of Police Powers Panel (ISoPPP) has published its 2025 Annual Report, offering a clear assessment of how police powers were used across Avon and Somerset and how community voices have helped drive improvements. 

Acting on behalf of the Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC), the Panel independently reviews the use of Stop and Search, Taser, and other forms of force through body worn video and police records. Its role is to ensure these powers are used fairly, proportionately and transparently. 

Strengthening scrutiny and governance 

2025 was a significant year of development. Following a joint internal review with the OPCC and the Constabulary, the Panel refreshed its Terms of Reference and introduced a more structured feedback process to ensure learning is captured and acted on more consistently. 

Panel Chair Desmond Brown emphasised the Panel’s renewed focus: 

“Scrutiny must lead to change; otherwise, it risks becoming symbolic.” 

Driving improvements in police practice 

One of the year’s key outcomes was the introduction of Avon and Somerset Police’s first formal definition of compliant handcuffing—a change prompted by concerns repeatedly raised by the Panel. This definition will support greater clarity for officers and strengthen future scrutiny. 

The Panel continued to highlight issues relating to Stop and Search, body worn video activation, communication tone and de-escalation. Its findings have informed recent improvements to policy, training and oversight. Chief Constable Sarah Crew QPM welcomed the Panel’s contribution: 

“Their work drives real improvement, supports accountability, and helps ensure our use of police powers remains both proportionate and community centred.” 

Focus on protecting children 

Adultification—where children are incorrectly treated as adults in police interactions—was a recurring theme in the Panel’s work. The report warns of the risks this poses to safeguarding and fairness. As the Chair stated: 

“Children must be treated as children, consistently and without exception.” 

This will remain a priority area for scrutiny in 2026. 

National recognition 

In November 2025, the Panel was named Runners Up at the Home Office’s Lord Ferrers Awards, recognising the dedication of volunteers who support transparency and accountability in policing. PCC Clare Moody congratulated the Panel: 

“The Panel has consistently demonstrated unwavering dedication. Their tireless efforts continue to inspire.” 

Increasing transparency in 2026 

A major focus for the coming year will be improving public awareness of the Panel’s role and impact. As the Chair noted: 

“Transparency must be active, not passive. Communities should know how police powers are being scrutinised, what themes are emerging, and how learning is translated into practice.” 

The report sets out plans to strengthen communication, enhance partnership working and ensure scrutiny continues to deliver meaningful, measurable improvements. 

The full 2025 Annual Report is available to download from the here.